Monday, May 3, 2010

Mint Oreo Cookie Ice Cream

Should I admit how many times I've made this particular ice cream in the last two weeks? No, I'll keep that to myself, but I will say it's more than 2 but less than 4.

If you have an ice cream maker, this is one of the best things you can make in it. If you don't have an ice cream maker, you should go get one, soon. :)

I have a KitchenAid ice cream attachment, and I love it. We have a small kitchen, so instead of having to store an additional appliance, I can keep the bowl in the freezer and it's ready at a moment's notice! It's dangerous, in a very good way.

I modified a basic ice cream recipe I found online about two years ago, and it. is. fabulous.

Mint Oreo Cookie Ice Cream

2 cups Heavy Cream
2 cups 1% milk (You can use 2% or whole milk for even creamier ice cream)
1 cup sugar
1/2 tsp salt
1 tsp pure vanilla extract
1 tsp peppermint extract
4-6 drops of green food coloring (optional)

1 cup of crushed Oreos (about 6-8 cookies)

Here's the hard part: Mix everything but the cookies in a large bowl with a whisk. Pour mixture into your ice cream machine and run per it's directions.  See, hard right?

Mine usually spins for about 20 minutes, but I keep an eye on it. Once it's doubled in volume and looks like soft serve, I dump in the cookies! It's the most exciting part!! 

Then, scoop it all  out into a tupperware container.  I've used multiple different types, it really doesn't matter which you use, whatever you have on hand. For fun, drop some additional crushed cookies onto the top and freeze until set. To set fully, it usually is best to freeze overnight. However, if you're anything like this ice cream lovin' household, after an hour or so, it'll be fairly set around the edges, and you can definitely make a bowl of it :)

I used to make this without the green food coloring, but lately, I just love the green color. Reminds me of my favorite drink from the 1970's, the Grasshopper. Seriously, my favorite. No, I wasn't really arround in the 70s...only as a baby in the LATE 70s. But still, I love that drink, and this ice cream is the perfect non-alcoholic version.

You may have noticed it's eggless...yes, it's true. No eggs. I'm too impatient for my ice cream at this point with the whole eggs in ice cream thing (i.e. custard). So maybe someday, but I have to be in the mood. Convince me otherwise?

So enjoy this wonderful eggless ice cream! I have many variations, which I will blog about later, but think of this as the base recipe.


  1. this looks amazing. But very dangerous! i'm afraid I'd eat the whole pot!

  2. that really looks good! i want an ice cream maker too!

  3. My 6 year old would go nutzo for this! He LOVES mint chocolate chip (but hates anything else mint...weird) and super loves Oreos!
    I'm gonna have to pull the ice cream maker out of the pantry ;)

  4. I have been wanting to get the attachment for my kitchen aide to make ice cream..this looks so great!!


  5. OOOhhh! This does sound incredible! I've just gotta find all the parts of my ice cream maker!

  6. I'm so excited!!! I just got a KA ice cream maker as a gift....i've only made 1 recipe so far with it since I received it last's fun to see what other people out there in "blog land" are making with their KA ice cream maker. This recipes looks devine!!! Thanks for sharing it! :-)

  7. Just stopping by from the Tidy Mom's I'm lovin' it and I have to admit I love (not like) LOVE Oreos!!!! Looks delish!!!

  8. YUMMM! we need to pull out our icecream maker!! I'm going to try this!!
    Thanks for sharing and linking up to I'm Lovin' It! Have a FABULOUS weekend!!

  9. Great recipe. I need an ice cream maker. It is so much healthier :)
    Happy Friday Follow. following your blog, come follow mine :)

  10. This is my comment: Mmmmmmmm, yummmmmmmm, mmmmmm, yummmmmm.

    *giggles* My ice cream maker is like the third best thing to ever happen to me. =)

    Isn't it so fun?

  11. Totally awesome recipe! I took a taste when it was done and realized I forgot to add the sugar. I felt like an idiot. I just added it in at the end and it tastes great!